Advertise
CoinTrust
BTC
ETH
BCH
SOL
DOGE
SHIB
  • News
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Altcoin
  • Market Cap
  • Learn
    • Buying Crypto
    • Crypto Mining
    • Crypto Exchanges
    • Knowledge
  • Crypto Casinos
    • Bitcoin Casinos
    • New Crypto Casinos
    • No KYC Crypto Casinos
    • Anonymous Crypto Casinos
    • VPN Friendly Crypto Casinos
    • Bitcoin Poker
    • Crypto Poker
    • Bitcoin Bingo
    • USDT Casinos
    • Offshore Online Casinos
    • Bitcoin Betting Sites
    • Crypto Sports Betting
    • Reddit’s Best Bitcoin and Crypto Casinos
No Result
View All Result
CoinTrust
  • News
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Altcoin
  • Market Cap
  • Learn
    • Buying Crypto
    • Crypto Mining
    • Crypto Exchanges
    • Knowledge
  • Crypto Casinos
    • Bitcoin Casinos
    • New Crypto Casinos
    • No KYC Crypto Casinos
    • Anonymous Crypto Casinos
    • VPN Friendly Crypto Casinos
    • Bitcoin Poker
    • Crypto Poker
    • Bitcoin Bingo
    • USDT Casinos
    • Offshore Online Casinos
    • Bitcoin Betting Sites
    • Crypto Sports Betting
    • Reddit’s Best Bitcoin and Crypto Casinos
No Result
View All Result
CoinTrust
No Result
View All Result

Home » SEC Commissioner Voices Dissent Over Rejection Of Bitcoin ETF

SEC Commissioner Voices Dissent Over Rejection Of Bitcoin ETF

Kelly Cromley by Kelly Cromley
Jul 27, 2018
in Bitcoin News, News
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0

Hester PierceYesterday, the SEC rejected a Bitcoin ETF backed by Winklevoss’ twins, founders of Gemini exchange, citing concerns of fraud and alleged price manipulation of Bitcoin. The exchange had also expressed concerns that over 75% of Bitcoin trading volume happens outside the US.

The application, which was filed by CBOE Global Markets, to list Bitcoin ETF on the Bats BZX Exchange was turned down based on a 3-1 vote. As expected the decision was a big disappointment to cryptocurrency market, leading to a sharp decline in the price of Bitcoin. Surprisingly, Hester Peirce, a SEC Commissioner has voiced her dissent to the ruling made yesterday.

Notably, about a year ago, the SEC rejected a similar application for Bitcoin ETF backed by Winklevoss twins. So far, the SEC has not approved any Bitcoin ETF for the reasons mentioned above. An approval would have led the way for institutional investors to invest in the asset. In June, an application seeking a rule change was filed. The application tried to address the concerns of the regulator.

Commissioner Pierce begins by saying

“I respectfully dissent from the Commission’s order disapproving a proposed rule change, as amended, to list and trade shares of the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust on Bats BZX Exchange, Inc. (“BZX”).”

The commissioner raises questions about the motivations behind the ruling

“In addition, I am concerned that the Commission’s approach undermines investor protection by precluding greater institutionalization of the bitcoin market. More institutional participation would ameliorate many of the Commission’s concerns with the bitcoin market that underlie its disapproval order. More generally, the Commission’s interpretation and application of the statutory standard sends a strong signal that innovation is unwelcome in our markets, a signal that may have effects far beyond the fate of bitcoin ETPs. I will discuss each of these issues in turn.”

Pierce opines that BZX will benefit by performing the conditional duties under the supervision of the SEC

“Because the disapproval order focuses on the bitcoin spot market, it does not give adequate weight to the important function that exchanges, as self-regulatory organizations (“SROs”), perform under our regulatory framework. BZX should, and would, play a central role in monitoring trading in shares of the Trust. In performing that function, BZX would exercise the responsibilities entrusted to it as an SRO and would be subject to Commission oversight. In exercising these responsibilities, BZX would have powerful regulatory and business incentives to ensure the integrity of the products that it lists for trading. Nothing in the record suggests that BZX is unwilling or unable to fulfill its responsibilities under the Exchange Act.”

The Commissioner also pointed out continuous repression against the market forces.

“The disapproval order discourages new institutional participants from entering this market. Worse, it suggests that approval for bitcoin ETPs will come only when bitcoin spot and derivatives markets have matured substantially, yet, at the same time, contributes to further delay in their maturation, as potential institutional investors may reasonably conclude that the Commission will continue to repress market forces for the foreseeable future. As long as these investors decline to enter the bitcoin market because there is no efficient vehicle that would reduce the costs of entry, the features of the bitcoin market that cause the Commission concern are likely to persist.”

Pierce also asked the SEC for “merit regulation”.

“By precluding approval of cryptocurrency-based ETPs for the foreseeable future, the Commission is engaging in merit regulation. Bitcoin is a new phenomenon, and its long-term viability is uncertain. It may succeed; it may fail. The Commission, however, is not well positioned to assess the likelihood of either outcome, for bitcoin or any other asset. Many investors have expressed an interest in gaining exposure to bitcoin, and a subset of these investors would prefer to gain exposure without owning bitcoin directly. An ETP based on bitcoin would offer investors indirect exposure to bitcoin through a product that trades on a regulated securities market and in a manner that eliminates some of the frictions and worries of buying and holding bitcoin directly. If we were to approve the ETP at issue here, investors could choose whether to buy it or avoid it. The Commission’s action today deprives investors of this choice. I reject the role of gatekeeper of innovation—a role very different from (and, indeed, inconsistent with) our mission of protecting investors, fostering capital formation, and facilitating fair, orderly, and efficient markets. Accordingly, I dissent.”

The SEC released a filing on its decision, citing ongoing concerns for investors.

“Although the Commission is disapproving this proposed rule change, the Commission emphasizes that its disapproval does not rest on an evaluation of whether bitcoin, or blockchain technology more generally, has utility or value as an innovation or an investment. Rather, the Commission is disapproving this proposed rule change because, as discussed in detail below, BZX has not met its burden under the Exchange Act and the Commission’s Rules of Practice to demonstrate that its proposal is consistent with the requirements of the Exchange Act Section 6(b)(5), in particular the requirement that its rules be designed to prevent fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices.”

The BZX exchange has claimed that Bitcoin is not easy to manipulate. The arguments were highlighted by the SEC in its filing.

“BZX argues, among other things, that its proposal is consistent with Exchange Act Section 6(b)(5) on the grounds that the ‘geographically diverse and continuous nature of bitcoin trading makes it difficult and prohibitively costly to manipulate the price of bitcoin’—and that therefore the bitcoin market ‘generally is less susceptible to manipulation than the equity, fixed income, and commodity futures markets’—and because ‘novel systems intrinsic to this new market provide unique additional protections that are unavailable in traditional commodity markets.’”

Although the points made in favor of Bitcoin ETF failed to convince the SEC, the cryptocommunity is hopeful that Bitcoin-related markets will gain acceptance in the future.

Previous Post

Bitcoin Plummets As SEC Rejects Winklevoss ETF Application

Next Post

Amazon Partners With Manifold To Offer Serverless blockchain services

Related Posts

spheron-chainbase-partner-to-power-ai-with-decentralized-data

Spheron and Chainbase Unite to Power AI with Decentralized Data

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 15, 2025
0

Spheron Network, a decentralized compute infrastructure provider, has announced a strategic partnership with Chainbase, an emerging omnichain data platform. This...

d3serve-labs-blockchain-model-domain-transfers

D3Serve Labs Proposes Blockchain Model for Domain Transfers

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 15, 2025
0

D3Serve Labs, operating independently from D3 Global Inc., has submitted a new patent application to the United States Patent and...

figure’s-$355m-blockchain-securitization-earns-s&p-ratings

Figure’s $355M Blockchain Securitization Earns S&P Ratings

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 15, 2025
0

Figure Technology Solutions has announced the successful securitization of $355 million in mortgage assets through its latest transaction, designated FIGRE...

daiko’s-virtual-pet-blends-real-dog-care-with-gamified-tech

Daiko’s Virtual Pet Blends Real Dog Care with Gamified Tech

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 15, 2025
0

Daiko, an Ireland-based technology company, has revealed plans to introduce a blockchain-powered Virtual Pet game that aims to bridge the...

Emerging Cryptocurrency Shakes Up Industry as Potential Alternative to Bitcoin: ‘True Innovation’

Emerging Cryptocurrency Shakes Up Industry as Potential Alternative to Bitcoin: ‘True Innovation’

by Mostafijur Rahman
Jun 14, 2025
0

A rising cryptocurrency project is turning heads across the blockchain industry, positioning itself as a credible alternative to Bitcoin—and it’s...

tass-hub-ziggy-zeigler-web3-partnership

TASS HUB and Ziggy Zeigler Team Up to Empower Web3 Creators

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 14, 2025
0

TASS HUB, a decentralized Web3 content marketplace built on the Solana blockchain, has announced an exclusive long-term collaboration with Ziggy...

Next Post
Amazon Partners With Manifold To Offer Serverless blockchain services

Amazon Partners With Manifold To Offer Serverless blockchain services

  • blackrock invests in colle web3

    COLLE: Pioneering AI Web3 Platform Receives Investment Boost from BlackRock

    by Kelly Cromley
    May 13, 2024
  • Router Protocol and OpenWorldSwap Partnership to Revolutionize DEX Market

    by Kelly Cromley
    Aug 6, 2024
  • Central Bank of Saudi Arabia Teams Up with Ripple to Transform Cross-Border Settlements

    by Kelly Cromley
    Aug 17, 2023
  • GameStop’s Digital Transformation: Embracing Blockchain and NFTs

    by Kelly Cromley
    Feb 2, 2025
  • Blockchain Based Sports Platform SportsMint Unveiled

    by Kelly Cromley
    Apr 30, 2024

Recent News

spheron-chainbase-partner-to-power-ai-with-decentralized-data
Market News

Spheron and Chainbase Unite to Power AI with Decentralized Data

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 15, 2025
d3serve-labs-blockchain-model-domain-transfers
Market News

D3Serve Labs Proposes Blockchain Model for Domain Transfers

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 15, 2025
figure’s-$355m-blockchain-securitization-earns-s&p-ratings
Market News

Figure’s $355M Blockchain Securitization Earns S&P Ratings

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 15, 2025
daiko’s-virtual-pet-blends-real-dog-care-with-gamified-tech
Market News

Daiko’s Virtual Pet Blends Real Dog Care with Gamified Tech

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 15, 2025
tass-hub-ziggy-zeigler-web3-partnership
Market News

TASS HUB and Ziggy Zeigler Team Up to Empower Web3 Creators

by Kelly Cromley
Jun 14, 2025

Categories

  • Altcoin News
  • Analysis News
  • Binance Coin News
  • Bitcoin News
  • Blockchain
  • Blog
  • Cardano News
  • Ethereum News
  • ICO News
  • Legislation News
  • Market Forecasts
  • Market News
  • News
  • Ripple
  • Ripple News
  • Solana News
  • Tether News
  • XRP

Cointrust

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Correction Request
  • Our Team

Legal

  • Disclaimer
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Popular

  • ICO Listings
  • Knowledge Base
  • All about Mining
  • Cryptocurrency Exchanges
  • How and Where to buy Cryptocurrency

Sitemap

  • News section
  • Sitemap
  • XML Sitemap

© 2024 CoinTrust.com.

CoinTrustCoinTrust

* DISCLAIMER: All information provided in CoinTrust is merely for informational purposes, we are not an investment advisor and not affiliated with any companies or ICO/Cryptocurrency Projects. To use this website you must accept our cookie policy, Disclaimer and Privacy Policies.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Altcoin
  • Market Cap
  • Learn
    • Buying Crypto
    • Crypto Mining
    • Crypto Exchanges
    • Knowledge
  • Crypto Casinos
    • Bitcoin Casinos
    • New Crypto Casinos
    • No KYC Crypto Casinos
    • Anonymous Crypto Casinos
    • VPN Friendly Crypto Casinos
    • Bitcoin Poker
    • Crypto Poker
    • Bitcoin Bingo
    • USDT Casinos
    • Offshore Online Casinos
    • Bitcoin Betting Sites
    • Crypto Sports Betting
    • Reddit’s Best Bitcoin and Crypto Casinos

© 2024 CoinTrust.com.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website.
If you continue to use this site you agree to allow us to use cookies, in accordance with our Cookie Policy.
I Agree